A value trap is a common expression used to characterize an investment that appeared to be a value investment but continues to decline in value indefinitely. A value trap stock will continue to decline, as its valuation gets even cheaper. Although investors might be looking for a bargain, they find themselves holding stock of a bad business.
Value investors look for companies that are cheaply priced. This means that they will often have low valuations, that essentially reflect both the current negative market sentiment towards that company and the unsurprising growth expectations.
Some value investors buy stocks simply based on low price-to-earnings, price-to-book, and other metrics. However, this is certainly not the best approach, and every aspect of the company should be considered in order to avoid value traps.
Value traps have low valuations
Value traps just like value stocks have a low valuation. This can reflect several things. One of them is the general consensus view of market participants that a particular company has a grim future ahead. Therefore value investors are essentially contrarians. Betting that the outlook for a particular business is not as bad as the market thinks it is.
So it happens that sometimes those value stocks, despite their low valuations continue to decline indefinitely. Or their valuations remain low for a long period of time. A company’s inability to grow or an increasing number of risks surrounding the business could indicate that it is a value trap.
Not everything that is cheap is actually good
Die-hard value investors will tend to look at nothing but the valuation of the company. Although this is an important step in every good investment, it should not be the only focus. The sustainability of the business, as well as its management, and its competitive advantages are some of the important factors to consider.
In order to avoid value traps, you should not consider stocks solely based on their valuations.
Value investing has changed
One of the most important things to avoid is to simply buy stocks based on metrics. This has worked in the past, and Mr. Market has been incredibly favorable for some deep-value investors like Ben Graham. However, financial markets have evolved. The kind of value stocks Ben Graham was buying in his heyday do not exist anymore.
In fact, valuations are now entirely different. You can still find undervalued stocks, but they certainly do not have the discount that they once had.
Due to how financial markets have evolved there are now several ways to monitor stock prices electronically. This unintentionally forces the market to be much more efficient. Means that valuations will tend to be more comparable, and huge disparities are hardly found.
DCF and value traps
One of the most interesting aspects of the market is how some investors and analysts try to value companies solely based on discount cash flow models. Although the present value of a stock might be higher than its price, there is no guarantee that the stock will ever reach that price level. Even if the discount cash flow model is flawless, sometimes we have to understand that the market will never agree with us on everything.
Image source: Freepik